Grice's Conversational Maxims: Definition & Examples | (2023)

Grice's conversational maxims were created by the British philosopher H. Paul Grice in the 1970s. Grice's conversational maxims, also known as The Gricean Maxims, are based on Grice's Cooperative Principle, which aims to explain how people achieve effective communication in everyday situations.

Grice's conversational maxims - definition

Grice believed that meaningful dialogue was characterized by cooperation and based his Cooperative Principle theory on the assumption that participants in a conversation usually attempt to be truthful, informative, relevant, and clear in order to facilitate successful communication. Based on these assumptions, Grice divided his cooperative principle into four conversational maxims.

Grice's maxims for conversation

The 4 Conversational Maxims are the Maxim of Quality, the Maxim of Quantity, the Maxim of Relevance, and the Maxim of Manner.

Grice believed that anyone wishing to engage in meaningful communication would follow these maxims and would assume that others would also be following them.

The Maxim of Quality

Abiding by the Maxim of Quality means not telling a lie on purpose. When following this maxim during communication, you should:

  • Only say things you believe to be true.
  • Not say things that you cannot back up with evidence.

'The capital of India is New Delhi.'

Here the speaker believes that they are telling the truth to the best of their knowledge.

The Maxim of Quantity

When following the Maxim of Quantity, it is important to not withhold information during communication that would be necessary to keep the conversation going. However, it is also important not to bombard our listeners with too much irrelevant information. When abiding by this maxim during communication, you should:

  • Make your contribution to the conversation as informative as required.
  • Not contribute more informative than required.

Speaker A: 'Do you know if Katie got on okay with her exams?'

(Video) [Introduction to Linguistics] Grice's Maxims, Implicature, Presupposition

Speaker B: 'Yes, I do. She did really well and got an A! '

Here speaker B could have ended their reply after 'yes, I do.' However, they shared all of the information they knew so as not to flout the Maxim of Quantity.

(Don't worry, we're going to cover flouting Maxims soon!)

Grice's Conversational Maxims: Definition & Examples | (1)Withholding desired information is a way of flouting the maxim of quantity. - StudySmarter Originals

The Maxim of relevance

Following the Maxim of relevance keeps conversations on track and helps prevent random conversations that lack continuity. This maxim also helps us to understand utterances in conversations that may not be initially obvious. When abiding by this maxim, you should:

  • Only say things that are relevant to the conversation.

Speaker A: 'Do you think Leo is dating someone new?'

Speaker B: 'Well, he goes to Brighton most weekends.'

Due to the Maxim of Relevance, we can infer that there is a link between Leo dating someone and him going to Brighton, and speaker B isn't just randomly telling us about Leo's trips to Brighton.

The Maxim of Manner

The Maxim of Manner mainly refers to the choice of words you use. For example, when following this maxim, we should avoid using big or overly complex words that we know our listeners won't understand and should try our best to be concise and coherent. When abiding by the Maxim of Manner, you should:

  • Avoid obscurity or ambiguity.
  • Be brief and orderly.
  • Try and be as clear as possible.

'I'm writing an essay on metonymy. It's a type of figure of speech!'

(Video) Pragmatics and Gricean Maxims

Here the speaker knew that it was possible that the listener wouldn't know the term metonymy and decided to give a quick explanation.

Breaking Grice's 4 conversational maxims - examples

Grice's Maxims are statements that express a rule of conduct; However, these conducts are often broken during communication. Grice did not assume that everyone would constantly follow these maxims. Instead, he found it interesting when the maxims were not respected, namely by being either violated or flouted.

Violating Grice's Maxims

When Grice's Maxims are violated, they have been broken surreptitiously (secretly) or covertly (undercover). This means that others involved in the conversation are unaware that a Maxim has been broken.

The most common maxims that get violated are the Maxim of Quality and the Maxim of Quantity.

  • Maxim of Quality is violated when an individual purposely tells a lie.
  • Maxim of quantity is violated when an individual secretly with holds information that someone else wants to know.

Violating Grice's Maxims is more serious than flouting them, yet the severity of the violation can vary. For example, telling a lie in court is arguably worse than telling a little 'white lie'.

Flouting Grice's maxims

Flouting Grice's Maxims is a lot more common than violating maxims and is usually considered more acceptable. When Grice's Maxims are being flouted, it should be apparent to all those concerned.

Being ironic, using metaphors, pretending to mishear someone, and using a tone of voice that does not match the content of what you are saying are all examples of flouting Grice's Maxims.

Let's take a look at some of the different ways in which the maxims are often flouted.

  • Maxim of Manner is flouted when speakers use many big words and technical jargon that they know their listeners won't understand.
  • Maxim of relevance is flouted when someone pretends to mishear what has been said to change the conversation.
  • Maxim of Quantity is flouted when someone does not answer a question in full, usually to be obtuse or even annoying.
  • Maxim of Quality is flouted when someone is being ironic.

(This is not an extensive list of all the ways Maxims can be flouted, just a few handy examples. Can you think of any other ways people flout Grice's Maxims?)

When individuals flout maxims, they usually expect the listener to understand the intended meaning. Maxims are even purposefully flouted at times by comedians and writers for comedic effect!

(Video) Gricean maxims

Here are a few discourse examples of Grice's Maxims being flouted.

Speaker A: 'Do you know if there is any food in the fridge?'

Speaker B: 'Yes, I do know.'

Here the Maxim of Quantity has been flouted as speaker B is with holding information from speaker A. This example is a flout and not a violation because everyone in the conversation is aware that information is not being shared.

Zack: 'Wow, this place is awesome. Where do they keep the Archies?'

Sheldon: 'In the bedroom of ten-year-old girls, where they belong.'

In this extract from The Big Bang Theory, Sheldon flouts the Maxim of Quality by giving an answer that both people know is not true. Here, the maxim has been flouted for comedic effect.

Speaker A: 'I'm not sure about this new guy I'm seeing. He never messages me back, and I think he's talking to someone else.'

Speaker B: 'Sounds like a real keeper!'

(Video) GRICE'S MAXIMS | The Art of Language | 732

Here the Maxim of Quality has been flouted. Speaker B is lying - they don't really think that the new guy is a real keeper - they are being ironic. Again, this is not a violation because everyone concerned knows that the truth isn't being told.

Speaker A: 'Are you okay? You look upset.'

Speaker B: 'Uh ... I'm fine.' (in a sad tone)

Here the Maxim of Quality has again been flouted as speaker B obviously isn't fine. Speaker B is expecting speaker A to infer something different from what is actually being said. Grice refers to this flout as an implicature. Conversational implicature refers to the extra meaning implied within discourse without necessarily being said aloud.

Grice's Conversational Maxims: Definition & Examples | (2)This girl is flouting the maxim of quality as she is lying. - StudySmarter Originals.

What are some criticisms of Grice's conversational maxims?

Grice's conversational maxims have been criticized as they fail to recognize that cooperation within conversations is culturally determined, as with most social interactions.

Grice's maxims are based upon expected behaviours within the Western world, and therefore, cannot be applied globally due to potential cultural differences (Clyne, 1994).¹ Additionally, several theorists have criticized the maxims for being too vague and overly ambiguous.

As a result of this ambiguity, Grice's maxims have frequently been misinterpreted and misrepresented as guidelines for etiquette and instructions on being polite. However, this is not their intention. The maxims are only ever meant to describe the commonly accepted traits of successful communication.

Grice's conversational maxims - key takeaways

  • Grice's conversational maxims were created by the British philosopher H. Paul Grice in the 1970s.
  • Grice's 4 Conversational Maxims are: Maxim of Quality, Maxim of Quantity, Maxim of Relevance, and Maxim of Manner.
  • Grice believed that anyone wishing to engage in meaningful communication would follow these 4 Maxims and would assume that others would also be following them.
  • Grice's Maxims are often broken and can either be violated or flouted.
  • Grice's Maxims have been criticized for not considering cultural differences and for being overly ambiguous.

¹ Clyne, M. Intercultural Communication at Work: Cultural values in discourse. 1994.

(Video) Grice's Cooperative Principle, Conversational Maxims, Quantity, Quality, Relevance, Manner

FAQs

What is Grice's conversational maxims? ›

Grice coins 4 maxims to govern daily conversation as a general rule. The maxims are Quantity, Performance, Value and Manner.

What are the Grice's four maxims in conversation explain two of them in a concise manner? ›

Avoid language which is difficult to understand, such as because it contains words that the listener doesn't know. Avoid ambiguity. Avoid ambiguous language which can be interpreted in multiple ways, and which therefore makes it difficult for your recipient to understand what exactly you're trying to say. Be brief.

What are the four Grice's maxims? ›

The four types of maxims suggested by Grice were:
  • Maxims of Quality. Be truthful. Only say that for which you have adequate evidence.
  • Maxims of Quantity. Provide as much information as required. Do not provide more information than is required.
  • Maxim of Relation. Be relevant.
  • Maxims of Manner. Avoid ambiguity.

What is the main purpose of the Grice's co operative principle during communication? ›

Even though Grice's cooperative principle is usually viewed more as a prescriptive command, the main purpose of this principle is usually to describe the real nature of normal conversations and how people should behave when communicating with one another (Bach, 2005).

What are some examples of maxims? ›

"Actions speak louder than words." / "The pen is mightier than the sword." "You're never too old to learn." / "You can't teach an old dog new tricks." "All good things come to those who wait." / "Time and tide wait for no man." "Many hands make light work." / "Too many cooks spoil the broth."

Who created Grice's maxims? ›

The philosopher Paul Grice proposed four conversational maxims that arise from the pragmatics of natural language. The Gricean Maxims are a way to explain the link between utterances and what is understood from them.

What is maxim of quantity example? ›

For example, let's say that A asks B "What did you have for breakfast this morning?" If B responds, "I had some toast and jam," B is obeying the maxim of quantity, by giving as much information as is needed. However, let's say B responds "I had some breakfast before yoga class.

What are examples of conversational maxims that we usually follow to be cooperative? ›

Key Takeaways: Grice's Conversational Maxims
  • Quantity: Say no less than the conversation requires. Say no more than the conversation requires.
  • Quality: Don't say what you believe to be false. Don't say things for which you lack evidence.
  • Manner: Don't be obscure. Don't be ambiguous. Be brief. ...
  • Relevance: Be relevant.
8 Sept 2019

What does conversational maxim mean? ›

Definition: A conversational maxim is any of four rules which were proposed by Grice 1975, stating that a speaker is assumed to make a contribution that: is adequately but not overly informative (quantity maxim) the speaker does not believe to be false and for which adequate evidence is had (quality maxim)

What are the principles of conversation? ›

Five Principles of Conversation
  • Each person is both the speaker and listener, sender and receiver.
  • Monologue is the opposite side.
  • Demonstrate respect for the other person.
  • Avoid negative criticism and negative judgement.
  • Keep the channels open.
  • Acknowledge the presence and importance of the other person.

What does the word maxims mean? ›

1 : a general truth, fundamental principle, or rule of conduct Mother's favorite maxim was "Don't count your chickens before they hatch." 2 : a proverbial saying advised her daughter with the maxim "marry in haste, repent at leisure" Synonyms More Example Sentences Learn More About maxim.

What is the most important cooperative principle? ›

Voluntary and Open Membership

The members are the most important part of a cooperative. Without dedicated and participating members, no co-op can succeed. To gain such a group of individuals, all co-ops need to remain voluntary organizations with membership opportunities for all.

What is cooperative principle according to Paul Grice? ›

Grice (1989) states the Cooperative Principle as follows: “Make your conversational contribution such as is required, at the stage at which it occurs, by the accepted purpose or direction of talk exchange in which you are engaged.” Furthermore, he develops the classification of maxims into: a.

What are the 7 principles of cooperative? ›

Cooperative Principles
  • Open and Voluntary Membership. ...
  • Democratic Member Control. ...
  • Members' Economic Participation. ...
  • Autonomy and Independence. ...
  • Education, Training, and Information. ...
  • Cooperation Among Cooperatives. ...
  • Concern for Community.
1 Dec 2016

What is a 5 letter word for maxim? ›

The crossword clue Maxim with 5 letters was last seen on the April 21, 2022. We think the likely answer to this clue is ADAGE.

What are the 3 pieces in maxim? ›

A complete maxim will include three pieces: the action, the circumstances under which we do that action, and the purpose behind that action.

What is maxim relationship? ›

Basic Idea. • The Maxim of Relation is one of the four. conversational maxims of the Cooperative Principle. • Grice proposes this maxim as an explanation for a certain kind of regularity in conversational behavior with respect to the relevance of information provided at each turn of a conversation.

What are maxims in linguistics? ›

From Longman Dictionary of Contemporary Englishmax‧im /ˈmæksɪm/ noun [countable] a well-known phrase or saying, especially one that gives a rule for sensible behaviour → sayingExamples from the Corpusmaxim• According to this principle, we interpret language on the assumption that its sender is obeying four maxims. •

What is the maxim of relevance? ›

Maxim of Relevance: Say things that are relevant to the topic under discussion. Prevents random, incoherent conversations lacking continuity; makes it possible to understand conversations such as the following: (5) A: Is Gail dating anyone these days?

What is conversational implicature and its example? ›

"Generally speaking, a conversational implicature is an interpretive procedure that operates to figure out what is going on... Assume a husband and wife are getting ready to go out for the evening: 8. Husband: How much longer will you be?

How do you violate maxim of quantity? ›

Violations of the maxims produce conversations that are noticeably odd. For instance, if someone asks, "Do you have a watch?" and you respond, "Yes, I do," you are violating the first maxim of quantity: You are being less informative than is required.

What is the difference between flouting a maxim and violating a maxim? ›

In flouting the maxim of quality, speakers convey their intention indirectly without deceiving the hearers while in violating the maxim of quality the speakers will straightforwardly convey their dishonest intention. Flouting the maxim of quality is most frequently used by major characters in their utterances.

What are the 4 cooperative principles? ›

Cooperative Principles
  • Member Economic Participation.
  • Autonomy and Independence.
  • Education, Training and Information.
  • Cooperation among Cooperatives.
  • Concern for Community.

Which maxim involves not saying things you believe to be false? ›

“... of Grice's two Maxims of Quality (which I call submaxims), the second seems to be a predictable extension of the first: Maxim 1: Do not say what you believe to be false. Maxim 2: Do not say that for which you lack adequate evidence.

When can you say that a person is flouting a maxim and not violating it? ›

The difference between when a maxim is violated and when it is flouted is that when someone is flouting a maxim, they are not deliberately trying to deceive or mislead their interlocutors, but they are deliberately not observing the maxims, in order for the interlocutors to understand another set of meaning (Paltridge ...

What is conversational maxims and Implicatures? ›

Summary. Conversational Implicature is a notion devised by Paul Grice in 1975. It looks at the relation between what people say and what they actually mean in a conversation. Grice developed four "maxims" of conversation, which describe what listeners assume speech will be like.

What is the maxim of quantity? ›

The Maxim of Quantity relates to the amount of information provided in conversations. It is one of the four conversational maxims that make up the Cooperative Principle.

What is flouting maxim of manner? ›

Flouting a maxim is the case when a speaker purposefully disobeys a maxim at the level of what is said with the deliberate intention of generating an implicature.

What is the importance of maxim of teaching? ›

Maxims of teaching act as the springboard which catalyzes the momentum of teaching-learning process and thus helps the teacher in achieving the pre-determined objectives of education besides providing contentment to both the learners as well as the teacher.

What is the benefit of maxims of teaching? ›

BENEFITS OF MAXIMS OF TEACHING:

Makes teaching joyful & interactive. Maxims makes teaching purposeful meaningful. To create creativity among the students. To analysis and synthesis by students.

What are the principles of maxims of teaching? ›

The different maxims of teaching are as follows:
  • Known to Unknown. It is based on the fact that a learner knows something. ...
  • Simple to Complex. First simple things should be taught and then complex things. ...
  • Concrete to Abstract. ...
  • Analysis to Synthesis. ...
  • Induction to Deduction. ...
  • Near to Afar. ...
  • Whole to Part. ...
  • Psychological to Logical.
24 Feb 2021

What are the 5 elements of conversation? ›

The five stages of conversations
  • INITIATION. As the first stage of conversation, initiation requires you to be open to interact and perhaps use small talk to help “break the ice”. ...
  • PREVIEW. ...
  • BUSINESS. ...
  • FEEDBACK. ...
  • CLOSING.

What are the four stages of conversation? ›

The Four Types of Conversations: Debate, Dialogue, Discourse, and Diatribe.

What are the characteristics of good conversation? ›

Your Weekly Eureka Moment
  • Be Respectful. Appreciate others' thinking. ...
  • Be Prepared. Focus on the topic, activate background knowledge, and make connections. ...
  • Be An Active Listener. Look at the person speaking. ...
  • Be Clear. ...
  • Inquire and Probe. ...
  • Show Comprehension.
  • Check Understanding. ...
  • Control Self.
18 Jan 2017

How do you use maxim in Word? ›

Maxim in a Sentence 🔉
  1. My grandmother had a wise maxim to help me get through all of my teenage crises.
  2. If Jack had heeded the maxim and looked before he leaped, he would not have bought the cheap house surrounded by drug dens.
  3. Treating others how I want to be treated is a variation of a maxim I learned as a child.

How do you write a maxim? ›

Make sure you're not saying things more than once. In other words, say things one time and move on; don't drag it out by repeating the same thing over and over again. That is, you shouldn't restate or reiterate the same point with different words.

What are the maxims of life? ›

7 Maxims to Live By (That Changed My Life)
  • Maxim 1: Live in the now. ...
  • Maxim 2: Surrender. ...
  • Maxim 3: The more something upsets you, the more it is meant for you. ...
  • Maxim 4: If it frightens you, do it. ...
  • Maxim 5: Whatever you do, do it 100%. ...
  • Maxim 6: Nobody owes you anything. ...
  • Maxim 7: Give what you seek.
30 Aug 2019

What is an example of a cooperative? ›

Agriculture cooperatives such as Blue Diamond or Land O'Lakes are examples of producer cooperatives. Consumer co-ops: Customers who purchase goods and services from the cooperative own a consumer co-op. Grocery co-ops are a well-known example of consumer cooperatives.

What is the main function of cooperatives? ›

The cooperatives' main purposes are to provide services and to offer employment for their members, as well as promote community development in the district.

What does Paul Grice mean by conversational implicature? ›

The theory of conversational implicatures is attributed to Paul Herbert Grice, who observed that in conversations what is meant often goes beyond what is said and that this additional meaning is inferred and predictable.

Why is the cooperative principle important? ›

Cooperatives serve members most effectively and strengthen the cooperative movement by working together. Concern for community. Cooperatives are a reflection of those they serve. While focusing on member needs, cooperatives work for the sustainable development of all communities.

Who gave the concept of cooperative principle? ›

Task A - What is Grice's Cooperative Principle in Conversation? We will use Paul Grice's (1975) influential 'Cooperative Principle' approach to describe how we infer unstated meanings in ordinary conversations and apply this to dramatic conversations. Your role in this task is to read and understand.

What are the six types of cooperative? ›

Here we define cooperatives by type of membership, or more simply, who owns the cooperative.
  • Consumer Cooperatives. ...
  • Worker Cooperatives. ...
  • Producer Cooperatives. ...
  • Purchasing or Shared Services Cooperatives. ...
  • Multi-stakeholder Cooperatives.

What are the 6 core values of a cooperative? ›

Cooperative values

Cooperatives are based on the values of self-help, self-responsibility, democracy, equality, equity, and solidarity.

What are the benefits of cooperative? ›

Advantages of a co-operative include that:

there are equal voting rights for members. this structure encourages member contribution and shared responsibility. liability for members is limited. there is no limit on the number of members.

What does Paul Grice mean by conversational implicature? ›

The theory of conversational implicatures is attributed to Paul Herbert Grice, who observed that in conversations what is meant often goes beyond what is said and that this additional meaning is inferred and predictable.

What does conversational maxim mean? ›

Definition: A conversational maxim is any of four rules which were proposed by Grice 1975, stating that a speaker is assumed to make a contribution that: is adequately but not overly informative (quantity maxim) the speaker does not believe to be false and for which adequate evidence is had (quality maxim)

What is the explanation of the relation maxim? ›

The maxim of relation, where one tries to be relevant, and says things that are pertinent to the discussion. The maxim of manner, when one tries to be as clear, as brief, and as orderly as one can in what one says, and where one avoids obscurity and ambiguity.

What does the word maxims mean? ›

1 : a general truth, fundamental principle, or rule of conduct Mother's favorite maxim was "Don't count your chickens before they hatch." 2 : a proverbial saying advised her daughter with the maxim "marry in haste, repent at leisure" Synonyms More Example Sentences Learn More About maxim.

What is conversational implicature with example? ›

Conversational implicature is the phenomenon whereby a speaker says one thing and thereby conveys (typically, in addition) something else. For example, in ‎(1) below, Harold says that Sally should bring her umbrella, but further conveys that (he believes that) it is likely to rain.

What is conversational implicature give me the example of that *? ›

"Generally speaking, a conversational implicature is an interpretive procedure that operates to figure out what is going on... Assume a husband and wife are getting ready to go out for the evening: 8. Husband: How much longer will you be?

What is implicature and its example? ›

1. Definition • Implicature is a technical term, which refers to what is suggested in an utterance, even though neither expressed nor strictly implied. • Example: John is meeting a woman this evening. +> The woman John is meeting this evening is not his mother, his sister or his wife.

What is the example of maxim of quantity? ›

For example, let's say that A asks B "What did you have for breakfast this morning?" If B responds, "I had some toast and jam," B is obeying the maxim of quantity, by giving as much information as is needed. However, let's say B responds "I had some breakfast before yoga class.

What are examples of conversational maxims that we usually follow to be cooperative? ›

Key Takeaways: Grice's Conversational Maxims
  • Quantity: Say no less than the conversation requires. Say no more than the conversation requires.
  • Quality: Don't say what you believe to be false. Don't say things for which you lack evidence.
  • Manner: Don't be obscure. Don't be ambiguous. Be brief. ...
  • Relevance: Be relevant.
8 Sept 2019

What is conversational maxims and Implicatures? ›

Summary. Conversational Implicature is a notion devised by Paul Grice in 1975. It looks at the relation between what people say and what they actually mean in a conversation. Grice developed four "maxims" of conversation, which describe what listeners assume speech will be like.

Why is maxim of relevance important? ›

Maxim of Relevance: Say things that are relevant to the topic under discussion. Prevents random, incoherent conversations lacking continuity; makes it possible to understand conversations such as the following: (5) A: Is Gail dating anyone these days?

What is flouting maxim of manner? ›

Flouting a maxim is the case when a speaker purposefully disobeys a maxim at the level of what is said with the deliberate intention of generating an implicature.

What is the difference between flouting a maxim and violating a maxim? ›

In flouting the maxim of quality, speakers convey their intention indirectly without deceiving the hearers while in violating the maxim of quality the speakers will straightforwardly convey their dishonest intention. Flouting the maxim of quality is most frequently used by major characters in their utterances.

What are the 3 pieces in maxim? ›

A complete maxim will include three pieces: the action, the circumstances under which we do that action, and the purpose behind that action.

Why are maxims used? ›

The Importance of Maxims. Maxims work because they pack a powerful insight into a very short space. This makes them very easy to remember, which in turn makes them more likely to be repeated later on.

How do you use maxim in Word? ›

Maxim in a Sentence 🔉
  1. My grandmother had a wise maxim to help me get through all of my teenage crises.
  2. If Jack had heeded the maxim and looked before he leaped, he would not have bought the cheap house surrounded by drug dens.
  3. Treating others how I want to be treated is a variation of a maxim I learned as a child.

Videos

1. Gricean Maxims Examples and How to Have a Better Conversation
(Advanced English with Mary Daphne)
2. Grice's Maxims
(Jamie Leedham)
3. Example of Grice's Maxim in Monster University movie
(Gita Rosita Sari)
4. Explained: Grice's Cooperative Principle
(Phloneme)
5. Dialogue Tips: Grice's Conversational Maxims
(E.G. Stone)
6. Grice’s Maxims in The Big Bang Theory Sitcom
(Son of Anwer)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Last Updated: 02/06/2023

Views: 6185

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Birthday: 1998-01-29

Address: Apt. 611 3357 Yong Plain, West Audra, IL 70053

Phone: +5819954278378

Job: Construction Director

Hobby: Embroidery, Creative writing, Shopping, Driving, Stand-up comedy, Coffee roasting, Scrapbooking

Introduction: My name is Dr. Pierre Goyette, I am a enchanting, powerful, jolly, rich, graceful, colorful, zany person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.